The information in this blog is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Consult a qualified attorney for advice on your specific situation. We make no guarantees about the accuracy or completeness of the information provided. Reliance on any information in this blog is at your own risk.
Creative businesses toss around the phrase “work for hire” as if it automatically transfers ownership of anything a contractor or employee produces. In Canada—and especially in Ontario—that assumption can be dangerous. The work-for-hire doctrine is a creature of U.S. copyright law, not Canadian law, and relying on it here can leave you without clear title to the intellectual property (IP) that drives your valuation.
Below we untangle the key distinctions between U.S. work-for-hire rules and Canadian IP-assignment requirements, outline the risks of getting it wrong, and explain how to draft contracts that truly secure ownership of code, designs, written content, and inventions.
What “Work-for-Hire” Means in U.S. Law
Under § 101 of the U.S. Copyright Act, a work is “made for hire” if it is:
- Created by an employee within the scope of employment, or
– - Created by an independent contractor under a written agreement that explicitly states the work is made for hire and fits into one of nine narrow categories (e.g., contribution to a collective work, motion picture, atlas).
If those conditions are met, the employer or commissioning party — not the individual creator — is deemed the author and first copyright owner. No separate assignment is needed.
Why Work-for-Hire Doesn’t Exist in Canada
The Canadian Copyright Act takes a simpler but stricter view:
- Employees: Copyright in works made “in the course of employment” automatically vests in the employer unless the employment contract says otherwise (s. 13(3)).
– - Independent contractors: The creator owns copyright by default. The hiring party acquires rights only through a written assignment signed by the creator (s. 13(4)).–
There is no statutory equivalent to the U.S. contractor work-for-hire provision. Saying “this is a work for hire” in a Canadian contract is legally meaningless unless it also includes an explicit assignment clause.
Patent, Trademark, and Industrial Design Nuances
- Patents: Inventorship always begins with the individual inventor. Employers secure ownership through employment agreements or assignments, plus recording with the CIPO patent office.
– - Trademarks: A mark’s use determines ownership; however, designers who create a logo own the copyright in the artwork unless it’s assigned. Without that assignment, you may own the mark but not the visual asset—a gap that complicates enforcement and re-branding.
– - Industrial designs: Rights vest in the creator; assignments must be in writing and recorded for full protection.
Risks of Assuming Work-for-Hire Covers Canada
Diluted Valuation: Investors and acquirers demand a clean chain of title. Missing assignments force last-minute scrambles to chase down contractors—or result in price chips and indemnity holdbacks.
–
Injunction Exposure: A disgruntled contractor can assert copyright, secure takedown notices, or seek an injunction, disrupting product launches or marketing campaigns.
–
Moral-Rights Claims: Even if economic rights are assigned, Canadian authors retain moral rights unless waived. Without explicit waivers, edits, re-mixes, and associations with certain brands can trigger lawsuits.Tax Credits and Grants: Programs like SR&ED require proof that the claimant owns or licenses the IP being commercialised. Unclear ownership jeopardises funding.
–
Tax Credits and Grants: Programs like SR&ED require proof that the claimant owns or licenses the IP being commercialised. Unclear ownership jeopardises funding.–
Essential Clauses for IP Security
Broad IP Assignment
“Contractor hereby irrevocably assigns to Company all right, title, and interest—including copyright, patent rights, industrial design rights, and trade-secret rights—in and to the Work Product.”
Moral-Rights Waiver
“Contractor waives in favour of Company and its successors all moral rights in the Work Product, including integrity and attribution rights, to the fullest extent permitted by law.”
Further Assurances
“Contractor will execute any documents and perform acts necessary to give effect to this assignment, including patent applications, at Company’s expense.”
Background Technology Licence
If contractors incorporate pre-existing code or templates:
“Contractor grants Company a perpetual, royalty-free licence to use any Background Technology embedded in the Work Product.”
Choice of Law
Select Ontario law and courts to ensure local enforceability and avoid U.S. work-for-hire confusion.
Employees vs. Contractors: Documentation Checklist
| Document | Employee | Contractor |
| Written Employment/Contract Agreement | ✔ | ✔ |
| Express IP-Assignment Clause | Recommended to eliminate doubt | Mandatory |
| Moral-Rights Waiver | ✔ | ✔ |
| Invention Disclosure Obligations | ✔ | ✔ |
| Confidentiality & Non-Solicit | ✔ | ✔ |
| Acknowledgement of Pre-Existing IP | ✔ | ✔ |
Spell out audit rights, interest penalties on late payments, and dispute-resolution forums. Tie renewals to minimum-royalty achievements.
Special Considerations for Software Development
- Open-Source Components
Require prior approval before a contractor adds GPL or other “viral” open-source code that could force disclosure of proprietary source.
– - Source-Code Delivery
Obligate delivery of repos, build scripts, and documentation upon milestone payments or termination.
– - Patent Rights
In agile development, inventions may surface mid-sprint; contracts should assign future inventions automatically and oblige cooperation in patent filings.
When You Do Want to License, Not Own
Sometimes a vendor retains proprietary tech while granting you a robust licence. In those cases:
- Negotiate a perpetual, irrevocable, royalty-free licence for your field and territory.
– - Ensure access to escrowed source code if the vendor goes insolvent.
– - Verify the vendor has secured all necessary assignments within its own supply chain.
How AMAR-VR LAW Can Help
Our IP and corporate teams:
- Audit existing contractor and employment agreements for ownership holes.
– - Draft Ontario-compliant templates with airtight assignment and waiver language.
– - Design open-source governance policies to prevent “licence creep.”
– - Record patent, trademark, and industrial-design assignments with CIPO.
– - Conduct due-diligence clean-ups before financing, M&A, or IPO events.
We translate complex IP statutes into clear, enforceable contracts that protect your innovation pipeline.
Conclusion
Work-for-hire language may satisfy U.S. counsel, but in Canada it leaves yawning gaps. Without explicit assignments and moral-rights waivers, independent contractors—not your company—own the code, designs, or content you paid for. Secure those rights in writing from day one to avoid valuation penalties, product delays, and litigation surprises.
Need to upgrade your contractor or employment agreements? Contact us today for a consultation. We’ll ensure your IP stays exactly where it belongs—inside your business and off your worry list.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
- Does “work for hire” language automatically transfer IP rights in Canada?
–
No. The U.S. “work for hire” doctrine has no equivalent in Canadian law. In Canada, independent contractors own copyright by default unless they sign a written IP assignment agreement transferring ownership to the hiring party.
– - What happens if there’s no written IP assignment with a contractor?
–
Without a written assignment, the contractor retains ownership of the intellectual property they create. This may limit your ability to commercialize, modify, sublicense, or enforce those assets, and can cause serious issues during financing or acquisition due diligence.
– - Are moral rights automatically waived when IP is assigned?
–
No. Even after an IP assignment, Canadian law grants authors moral rights to control how their work is modified, attributed, or associated with products or causes. A separate written moral-rights waiver is necessary to fully secure usage rights.
– - Do employment agreements in Canada need IP assignment clauses?
–
Yes. While Canadian law generally assigns IP created by employees “in the course of employment” to the employer, it is still best practice to include explicit IP assignment and moral-rights waiver clauses in employment agreements to eliminate any doubt.
– - How can AMAR-VR LAW assist with IP ownership issues?
–
AMAR-VR LAW audits current contractor and employment agreements, drafts Ontario-compliant assignment and waiver clauses, creates open-source governance policies, files assignments with CIPO, and ensures IP chain-of-title is clean for financing, M&A, or IPO readiness.